A detailed comparison of the Proxy and Decorator design patterns in C#, focusing on their intent rather than their near-identical structure. The proxy controls access to an object (gatekeeping, authorization, lazy init, caching that skips the inner call), while the decorator always delegates and adds behavior (logging, metrics, retry). The post covers lifecycle ownership differences, transparency, DI registration in ASP.NET Core, and how to compose both patterns together. A decision criteria table and FAQ section help developers choose the right pattern for their use case.

14m read timeFrom devleader.ca
Post cover image
Table of contents
Quick Refresher: The Proxy PatternQuick Refresher: The Decorator PatternStructural Similarity: Nearly Identical Class DiagramsIntent Difference: Access Control vs Behavior EnhancementLifecycle Ownership: Who Creates the Real Object?Transparency: Full Delegation vs Restricted AccessSame Problem, Both Ways: LoggingDI Integration: Similar Registration, Different PurposesCan They Work Together?Decision Criteria TableFrequently Asked QuestionsWrapping Up Proxy vs Decorator in C#

Sort: