I tracked down the guy who gave a negative review to Battlezone 98 Redux after playing for over 8,000 hours, and came away convinced he was right

The post discusses Scott Smith, also known as Herp McDerperson, who left a negative review for Battlezone 98 Redux after playing it for over 8,000 hours. Smith pinpoints numerous issues with the remaster, from bugs to changes that affected the multiplayer experience. His criticisms stem from a deep connection to the original game and a sense of loss for the community that once thrived. Despite leaving a harsh review, Smith continued playing to help others, revealing a complex relationship with the game and its community.