Kent Beck recounts a proposal he developed to resolve the logger-vs-environmentalist conflict in southern Oregon by redesigning incentive structures. Instead of paying loggers for the current harvest, he proposed paying them based on the health of the forest 10 years later, converting short-term extraction incentives into long-term stewardship incentives. This would create a reinforcing loop: careful thinning leads to healthier forests, less resistance, and more logging opportunities. The deferred payment rights could be sold as financial instruments to local investors, and environmentalists could serve as auditors of forest health. Despite being invited to present the idea at a community summit, Beck passed on the opportunity. He reflects that entrenched interests often prefer staying entrenched, but that changing rules is a prerequisite for changing behavior.
Sort: